Expert mode: understanding the circle of confusion
A little theory, in pictures.
Entirely optionalYou don't need to read this page to use DoF Viewer: in Normal mode, the app takes care of everything.
Proven foundationsThe calculations rest on classic depth of field optics and the 0.030 mm reference value for 24×36.
Going furtherThis page explains where that value comes from, and why Expert mode recalculates it for your prints.
The circle of confusion (CoC) is the size of the smallest spot the eye sees as sharp. It depends on three things: the viewer's visual acuity, the viewing distance, and the enlargement ratio between the sensor and the final picture. The usual 0.03 mm value for 24×36 assumes one very specific case. Here is where it comes from, why it is not always enough, and how Expert mode recalculates it for a more reliable depth of field (DoF).
The standard viewing conditions
The classic calculation assumes the picture is viewed from 25 cm. Our field of view is about 60°: at that distance it covers a 29 cm circle, in which a 16 × 24 cm picture fits.
Figure 1 — At 25 cm, a 60° field of view covers a 29 cm circle, i.e. a 16 × 24 cm picture.
The acuity of the eye
At 25 cm, the eye resolves details of about 0.1 mm. That is equivalent to a test chart of 5 line pairs per millimetre (lp/mm). One line pair measures 0.2 mm: that is the CoC on the final picture.
Figure 2 — 0.1 mm at 25 cm: 5 lp/mm, i.e. a 0.2 mm CoC on the final picture.
From print to sensor
To find what this CoC means on the sensor, apply the enlargement factor. From 24 × 36 mm to 240 × 160 mm, it is about 6.7. The CoC on the sensor is therefore 0.2 / 6.7 ≈ 0.03 mm.
Figure 3 — CoC on the sensor = 0.2 mm / 6.7 ≈ 0.03 mm.
But only under those conditions
The 0.03 mm CoC holds for a 16 × 24 cm picture viewed from 25 cm, with 0.1 mm acuity. What happens with a 50 × 75 cm print, or when viewing from 50 cm?
Figure 4 — If the print size or the distance changes, 0.03 mm is no longer the right criterion.
The 0.03 mm CoC is no longer accurate enough, and neither is the DoF calculation. That is what Expert mode is for.
The three Expert mode settings
Expert mode keeps the 16 × 24 cm picture as its reference, but recalculates the CoC from the real conditions: visual acuity, viewing distance and print size.
Visual acuity
Three levels are offered. Each sets the smallest visible detail as a fraction of the viewing distance.
Figure 5 — The three acuity levels, drawn to scale: the lower the acuity, the larger the smallest visible detail.
Viewing distance
The further away you are, the fewer details the eye resolves. The smallest visible detail is proportional to distance: at 50 cm it is twice as large as at 25 cm.
Figure 6 — Smallest visible detail against distance (log scales). The nominal CoC is twice that detail.
Print size
A new enlargement ratio is computed to keep the CoC consistent with the chosen acuity and distance. The 16 × 24 cm reference is in orange.
Figure 7 — Available print sizes, to scale. R = ratio to the 16 × 24 cm reference picture.
The final CoC (Expert CoC) takes all three conditions into account.
The reasoning, step by step
How do these three settings lead to the final CoC? In six steps, with the same test chart and the same red circles. Enlargements are drawn with a ratio of 2, for illustration.
1. The reference CoC matches the chosen acuity and distance.2. When the picture grows, the stripes grow too.3. But the eye has stayed at the same distance: acuity and CoC no longer match.4. A new CoC is worked out that takes the enlargement into account.5. The picture is enlarged with that ratio.6. Stripes and new CoC are consistent again with the chosen conditions: it can be used to compute the DoF.
Last step: back to the sensor
The CoC still has to be carried over to the sensor, using the ratio between the reference picture and the sensor.
Figure 9 — The CoC on the sensor is (CoCnominal / Renlargement) / Rsensor.
In short
Four settings go into the Expert CoC. The result is a more accurate estimate of the DoF, because it takes the viewing conditions of the final picture into account.
Figure 10 — From the user's settings to the DoF: inputs in blue, result in orange.
CoCnominal = 2 × acuity(d)
with acuity(d) = d / 2500 (Medium), d / 3000 (High) or d / 1250 (Low)
CoCexpert = CoCnominal / (Renlargement × Rsensor)
Rsensor: ratio between the 16 × 24 cm reference picture and the sensor (≈ 6.7 for 24×36).
Renlargement: ratio between the chosen print and the 16 × 24 cm reference picture.
The factor 2 comes from acuity: 0.1 mm corresponds to a 0.2 mm CoC, i.e. one line pair.
In other words: CoC on the sensor = smallest visible detail on the print ÷ total enlargement (print / sensor).
Worked examples (24×36, Medium acuity)
Print
Distance
CoC on the print
Total enlargement
CoC on the sensor
16 × 24 cm
25 cm
0.2 mm
≈ 6.7×
≈ 0.030 mm
50 × 75 cm
25 cm
0.2 mm
≈ 20.8×
≈ 0.0096 mm
50 × 75 cm
50 cm
0.4 mm
≈ 20.8×
≈ 0.019 mm
16 × 24 cm
50 cm
0.4 mm
≈ 6.7×
≈ 0.060 mm
A large print viewed up close calls for a much smaller CoC, and therefore less depth of field; viewing from further away relaxes it.
In the app
In Expert mode, the CoC can become smaller than the sensor's pixel size. DoF Viewer still computes the DoF, but the value is no longer realistic; the fields concerned turn red.